One of the most respected draft gurus around is Rick Gosselin of the Dallas Morning News. He posted his 2010 NFL draft grades and gave the Colts a C.
SB Nation's Stampede Blue responded to this "meh" grade:
Personally, I think this is weak on Gosselin's part. A "C" grade is a weak grade for a draft. Either clarify that weak grade with reasons why the team seemingly screwed up, or don't grade at all. If you are wrong about that "C" grade two years from now, fine. Who cares? There's nothing "wrong" about being wrong when you are evaluating draft grades from a media perspective. Their job is to be critical, and often they have to do this with little or no real information.
Stampede Blue's BBS has noticed a trend with the Colts drafting -- the second and third round picks the last four years haven't been very good.